Tomato Killer on the Loose
80Tomato Plant Carnage
What is Eating My Tomatoes?
There is a tomato killer on the loose in the neighborhood, a marauder on the prowl just as dawn breaks. He’s stealthy, making no noise, casting no shadow. He enters my garden by way of a large common lawn he traverses after leaving the cover of a nearby creek bed that is surrounded by trees and shrubs. Once in the garden, he eats tomato leaves, stems, newly set tomatoes, and lovely, skirted tomato flowers. In his wake he leaves a ravaged tomato plant, a half of a gnawed green tomato lying on the ground a few feet away from the plant, and a smelly string of slimy scat on the lawn. He also leaves unidentifiable impressions in the dry mulch, but none on the bare garden ground that is parched and rock-hard from unseasonably hot, dry weather; what he does leave on the hard, dry ground are drops of liquid speckled with a few immature tomato seeds.
In his pre-dawn raid, the tomato killer devoured the upper third of a four-foot high tomato plant and 16 and one-half green tomatoes out of 19. I know this number exactly, because I’d counted the set tomatoes just the evening before. Oddly, he took no bites from the leaves and stems at the bottom two-thirds of the plant, although he did strip that area of flowers and set tomatoes.
When I first see this devastation in the garden, shortly after dawn, I want to cry out in frustration. Apparently it isn’t enough that I’ve already put my heart, mind, and body into waging war in the garden against bindweed, bugleweed, and Canada thistle. Although I’ve made great progress toward victory on that front, now I have a new invader to contend with.
I think this tomato killer is a mercenary hired by the garden weeds in their attempt to regain the ground they lost in my ongoing war against them.
My fervent hope is that this marauder gets a very bad belly ache from eating tomato stems, leaves, flowers, and green tomatoes.
I Begin with the Process of Elimination
I decide to begin solving this mystery with what I know the tomato killer can’t be, based on our local wildlife population and the evidence I’ve gathered so far.
It can’t be a tomato horn worm. Although two or three tomato horn worms can strip an entire tomato plant in a matter of hours, the horn worms are not yet active in our area. Plus, horn worms don’t eat a half of a green tomato and then toss the other half on the ground a few feet from the plant.
It can’t be a groundhog. A groundhog would have left bits and shreds of plant material on the ground (which the marauder did not do) and also would have started eating closer to the ground. In all likelihood, a groundhog would have destroyed the entire plant either by eating it all (they aren’t called “hogs” for nothing) or by eating through each stem, causing the top growth of the stem to topple to the ground.
It can’t be a squirrel. The bird lovers in our neighborhood provide the ideal environment for a squirrel by setting out bird feeders and bird baths. No squirrel in our neighborhood in its right mind would ever be driven to eat a tomato plant!
Slimy Scat
It can’t be a deer. This garden pest is a bit more difficult to eliminate. Indeed, a deer could eat the top third of the plant and could use its slender snout to root out the largest green tomatoes from behind the leaves and stems at the bottom two-thirds of the plant. However, a deer would have left its scat, which looks nothing like the scat the marauder left behind.
It can’t be a rabbit. Rabbits are not tall enough to take off the top third of a four-foot high tomato plant.
It Is Time To Re-examine the Evidence and Make Some Speculations
Now that I am sure what the marauder is not, I need to take a closer look at the clues at hand to figure out what the marauder is.
The scat. I’ve never seen anything quite like it. It has a dark gray color and is pointed at one end. If it were stretched out instead of partially folded onto itself, it would be about four inches long. A bit of research leads me to the conclusion that it is not any kind of dog or cat poo; rather it is the fecal matter of a fox.
Drops of liquid on the ground. Whatever animal wreaked havoc on the tomato plant did it shortly before dawn. If the liquid had been left during the previous evening, or even during the wee hours of the morning, it would have dried before I saw it just after dawn. I do not know if the liquid is tomato juice that escaped when the fruit was bitten, or if the liquid is the tomato killer’s drool. What I can assume is that the culprit is active before dawn, in which case it is probably nocturnal. Although foxes in the wild are not necessarily nocturnal, they tend to develop that behavior in populated areas in order to avoid contact with humans and their machines.
This Tomato Escapes the Carnage
Top growth destroyed while tomatoes close to the ground were removed without damaging the lower leaves and stems. This clue puzzles me. The stems that were destroyed were very long, arching over so that their leaves were rather close to the ground, forming a kind of umbrella over the interior parts of the tomato plant. It could be that the marauder sampled these leaves and stems first, munching higher and higher until a final bite made what was left of the stem snap upright with the dessicated end too high to reach. If that is so, then the animal just moved on to the next low-hanging leaf and repeated the exercise. At some point, the seriously big fruits closer to the ground would have become more exposed, and a sleek snout, which a fox surely has, would have easily found the treasure.
I Bring Memory and Experience to Speculation
As I ponder the evidence, three recent experiences come to mind.
A few weeks ago a neighbor asked if I had heard terrifying sounds in the night, as if an animal were being attacked and killed. Indeed I had, over the course of two or three nights. Neither of us had a clue as to what the source of the sounds might be.
Then, a few days later, another neighbor asked if I knew about the red fox seen making its rounds at dusk and dawn. No, I had not.
Is This the Tomato Killer?
Finally, three days before the attack of the tomato killer, while sitting on my patio just before dawn enjoying a cup of coffee and waiting for the sun to rise, I saw the fox, his nose to the ground, as he left the forested creek bed and headed out onto the common lawn. Suddenly, he froze in his tracks, as I had been frozen in my chair since seeing him, and after just a second or two he turned his head in my direction. He was only 20 feet or less away from me. His eyes locked onto mine. Just as suddenly, he snapped his head back and took off running.
Is the Tomato Killer a Fox?
Conclusions spawned from evidence, anecdote, and experience are not sufficient proof that the marauder is a fox. Proof will come from catching the culprit in the act, designing an experiment to proove my theory that this tomato carnage is the fox’s fault, or the fox will have to confess (which I don’t see happening).
Why would a fox be here?
I’ve been in this townhome community in a now densely populated exurb of Philadelphia, Pennsylvania, USA, for nearly 13 years. I’ve seen deer, groundhogs, and skunks from time to time. These wildlife species make their appearances in my neighborhood for a while, and then they are gone. We neighbors know that wildlife is being displaced from natural habitats, as this still partially rural area continues to be developed with residential and commercial properties. Five years ago it was the groundhogs, three years ago the deer and the skunks. This year, it is the red fox, Vulpes vulpes.
Why would a fox eat tomato plants complete with leaves, stems, fruits, and flowers? It is hot and dry here. I suspect the fox is thirsty. Since I water the tomato plants daily, they are full of water, while the natural stream beds and ponds here are dry. It is sad that a fox has to resort to a tomato plant to quench his thirst.
My Dog's Hair as Fox Repellant
Evidence of a Footprint
I Move on To Protect My Garden from the Presumed Fox
On the day of the tomato plant devastation in the garden I started a thread in the HubPages forum asking for help in solving the mystery of the nocturnal marauder. Helpful posters contributed their thoughts and experiences.
That night, adding their suggestions and experiences to mine, I reached into a stash of my dog’s saved groomed fur and staked the fur around the devastated tomato plant and its two tomato plant companions that had not yet been traumatized by the presumed fox.
The next morning, I found that the culprit had visited the garden, the evidence being a new pile of fox-specific scat, had taken a step close to the devastated tomato plant, seen by a displacement of the mulch, but had turned away, meaning that there was no further destruction.
My dog Cinnamon, now resting in peace, is protecting the garden at least for now.
The grander issues of protecting displaced wildlife are yet to be resolved. And I have yet to prove that the fox is the tomato killer.
More Hubs by Sally's Trove about Gardening
CommentsLoading...
Sherlock Holmes would have been foxed too! :D
But a hurrah for Cinnamon...may she rest in peace! :)
(An aside...way back when I was wee, I had a fascination for tomatoes I hear...would sneak into my mother's plants (which were taller than me then) and eat all the ripe tomatoes..till one day I was caught red-handed...literally! :P)
How cute is this, I love this story my friend, and I have foxes running around and wants to eat my tiny dog, it has already taken everyone's outdoor cats, it's simply amazing how brave they are...great story thumbs up
Now that sounds like the stuff the best detective stories are made of. I can almost see the headline: 'Vas it the Vulpes?' Oh Sally - I'm sure you're frustrated about those tomatoes but what a wonderful tale you weave around them! And that fox - I hope he finds food that he really wants someplace else and doesn't have to make do with tomatoes!
In this Hub, ST, you have out-marpled Miss Marple
(http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Miss_Marple)
and out-durrellel Gerald Durrell (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gerald_Durrell).
Wonderful reading. More power to your pen ST.
Wow, a lovely story, well laid out and followed through. Thank you.
Oh no, not the tomatoes... you silly old fox go for the squash instead (I don't like squash). How frustrating when you've nurtured these plants from small on and you're waiting and already anticipating some fabulous vine ripened tomatoes... I know just how you feel.
The tomato and cucumber killers in my neck of the woods are back-stabbing little monsters... much closer to home, the culprits over here are my own chickens--- the pain, the unbearable pain of being hurt thus by my own beloved flock...woe is me. I thought it might be a rabbit or two until I caught three of my feathered supposed friends taste testing each and every tomato and cucumber in an almost 1/4 acre garden.
Hahahaha... Chicken Paprikas will be served soon, want to come for dinner? Bring your Mom too there will be plenty... and while your here we'll make a stylish fox fur hat too.
What a great hub once again
hope you're well
kindest regards Zsuzsy
Well, fox droppings, that little rascal. How dare he? Maybe if he sampled just one or two tomatoes, but 16.5 out of 19? That's just greedy.
I loved the way you wove the story into a mystery. Beautifully told and cute, I was captivated.
I know what it is! I can see it now, as it has moved into my garden, Let me go out and take a photo of it to send you. My God, it's fearsome, it's a .... oh no, it's got me it .....nooooo ..... aaaaaaaaaaaarch!!!!!!!!
Just wanted you to know, I put out an APB for the middle of the night marauder! I considered an AMBER alert for the tomatoes, but I fear it's too late for them :(
This is my favorite garden how to of all time!MORE!
Well, gee, Sally, thanks for sharing the picture of the fox poop. haha. We have foxes in our neighborhood and I am glad to see them. They eat mice, rats, and other vermin. I can't imagine they would eat tomato plants but your clues sure point to Mr. Fox. I love a mystery and this was just great!
You can find audio samples of fox screams on the internet to be sure. The sound they make is just horrible!
We had tomato blight here last year. Hope we do not get it again.
The heat wave has caused our squash to just get gigantic! I was down there this morning and it feels like a jungle!
I'm thinking they were aiming to make fried green tomatoes :)
ST - I hate to break the news, but gray scat results when doggies eat lots of fresh-from-the-garden 'maters. Cinnamon is the sneak. ;->
Sally, How amazing how you describe your hub til the end I was holding my breath and im thinking without knowing that it could be a fox!! I was siting in the dark the other night, little that I know it was a fox walking on the sidewalk!!they are coming out more in more lately...Thank you for sharing sally..I am sorry for your lost tho you been working so hard in your garden!
Love always.
Flyingpanther
I'd love to send you some squashes, but we've given them away here already and eaten the rest ourselves.
I havent seen foxes here but I hear coy dogs all the time.
Sherri, we live in the suburbs and a have a fox! It isn't afraid of our huge dogs, either. In fact, it sometimes comes into our yard when I let the Danes out in the middle of the night. I think this one is lonely and wants to befriend our pooches.
I'm so sorry your maters got mauled, and I hope the ones you have left continue to grow and thrive!
At the barn, every time someone sees a mangey fox, we call our friendly wildlife rescuer and she laces chicken breast or a dead rat with Ivermectin and sets it out in the fox-freeway. Now we have a whole little family of happy shiny foxes. If you can capture your thief, we can put him with the ones at the barn - we don't have any tomatoes!
Love you, love your hubs. If you need more hair, Avi made you some.
Uhh... I... Errrr... :)
Very intertaining. You had me hooked from beginning to end. I love the way you presented this problem like a mystery. Fantastic job. You're quite the writer.
Sally what a delightful mystery--you sound like me with your deductive elimination of possibilities. I think you Sherlocked it well and in gratitude for the fox's help in eliminating other pests, I suggest you leave a bowl of water just outside the fur barrier to both thank and give him no reason to pursue your tomato treasures. =:)
Pat writes: As soon as I got to the photo of the animal scat I thought "fox". I've never experience a fox eating tomatoes, but it makes sense if the weather has been dry for a while.
Tricia lives near the edge of our town and has had foxes in her garden for several years.
I live near the middle of town, with no open countryside near by. Last winter we had an exceptional amount of snow, lasting for days. One snowy day I saw a large fox in my garden. Maybe the cold weather and lack of town drove it into town.
The trouble is, Mr Fox seems to like it in town - or at least the area around my garden. I am mighty fed up with fox droppings on my lawn!
Quite the 'murder' mystery, indeed. Who's murdering the tomatoes??
While I have some vegetables planted, we've not (knock wood) had any problems with marauders. We're pretty surrounded by urban sprawl, and even though there is an empty field behind us, and large 1/2 acre lots in this area, there are few invaders. Certainly no deer or fox. The occasional skunk or raccoon, but they don't seem to have a taste for vegetables.
Perhaps a security camera setup would catch your intruder for sure! ;-) (If only those things did not cost so much!)
You can find what kind of animal it is by tasting the scat.
No you can't! Don't do it!
I thought foxes only went for chickens, didn't know there are vegetarian ones around??? Good luck with finding out whether it is the fox or not. Funny hub.
It takes a brave woman to post photos of poo!! LOL! Great story and happy tomato harvesting!
Good stuff here! :) Bravo for your bravery and kudos for your cunning as well as your writing!
What great powers of observation you have! I loved every word, and saw a little further into how your wonderful mind works, if you don't mind my observations of you. =))
Now, your wonderful descriptions remind me, as they always do, of a story my husband tells about a police investigation of a midnight theft from a store.
He made copious notes, observations, and lists of probable point of entry, what was taken, and possible exit from the store, as well as time of incident.
Then, he began to interview people who frequented the area. Would that he had started there, but cops are often locked into their routine.
One older man was very enlightening. He said something like this: "I think he came in from the roof, those old roofs and skylights are probly pretty easy to break down or take loose. Then, I think he had a small pinlight flashlight so as not to attract attention, and had brought a cloth bag, like a military duffle bag most likely. Now, he had to have come down on top of a high shelf, since draggin a ladder was not likely. That would also allow him to be able to leave with the heavy bag, you know, he could just toss it up on the shelf and then put it on his shoulder or tie it to him as he climbed back out onto the roof.
Now that would lead us to think he's a wiry thin and probably young feller. Yep, I think that's what happened."
Lynn looked at him and said "Yeah, well how'do ya figure all that?"
He replied "Cuz that's what I saw. Yep, that pert near describes it."
oh.
You "pert near" caught that fox in the act, and I vote "Guilty!" on all counts.
LOL, a delightful read, my dear friend. I love every clever deduction, Ms. Private-Eye-Protector-Of-All-Living-Things!
The Dog Hair, how ingenious! And who would not suspect you of saving a piece of dear CinCin. I cannot yet read that Hub, I'll have to pick a day when I'm strong.
A very enjoyable read. Definitely worth sharing. Sly fox, lol! I loved how you wrapped this up into a mystery read. Keep them coming! :)
Sally - I'm back. Though we have foxes in our neighborhood, I have not had the pleasure of hearing one scream. Unbelievably, we also had what I think may be a coyote. The idea of wild animals in the suburbs fascinates me. I've linked this to my hub about that subject, if that's okay with you.
very informative hub. thanks
Luckily we have tomato horn worm only well I don't like tomato horn worm too. They still kill tomato plants. But a fox that is too much. Thanks for the information.
Hi Sally this hub was surely one of a kind. When I write about tomato pests I'm sure to include foxes and link it back to you :D.
It's coming soon :)
but my tomato pests were basically just caterpillars and worms as well as occasional diseases :)
we don't have foxes out here :D
I saw a fox once, sauntering down the street during the day as if he owned it.
Great hub! (Poor tomatoes!)






































bayoulady Level 1 Commenter 22 months ago
Whoo hoo! I almost HAD to peek at the conclusion, but I held myself in check.Quite the garden mystery.
I love the way you eliminated each suspect as the tomato killer. It does sound as if you've nailed it. I vote that the fox is guilty!